Menu
Close
Sign In
Exit
Search Night of Mystery
Search for:
Search
0
No products in the cart.
0
No products in the cart.
Shop Mysteries
Most Popular
Themes
Most Popular Mysteries
View All
Y2K Chaos
Murder At Gatsby’s Gala
Totally Rad 80s Prom Gone Bad
All
Most Popular Mysteries
View All
Trailer Park Tragedy
A Clueless Murder
Ho Ho Homicide
Top Sellers
Top Sellers Mysteries
View All
Y2K Chaos
A Villain’s Vendetta
Murder At Gatsby’s Gala
Trending
Most Popular Mysteries
View All
A Villain’s Vendetta
Trailer Park Tragedy
Murder in Margaritaland
All Time
Most Popular Mysteries
View All
Trailer Park Tragedy
Totally Rad 80s Prom Gone Bad
Murder At The Juice Joint
Classic
Top Classic Mysteries
View All
Murder At The Juice Joint
Y2K Chaos
Murder At The Deadwood Saloon
1920s
Top 1920s Mysteries
View All
Murder At Gatsby’s Gala
Murder At The Juice Joint
Murder of a Millionaire
80s/90s/00s
Top 80s/90s/00s Mysteries
View All
Totally Rad 80s Prom Gone Bad
Murder At The Juice Joint
Happily Never After
Western
Top Western Mysteries
View All
Murder At The Deadwood Saloon
Happily Never After
Murder Among The Mateys
Pirates
Top Pirates Mysteries
View All
Murder Among The Mateys
Murder At The Deadwood Saloon
Murder Under The Big Top
Circus
Top Circus Mysteries
View All
Murder Under The Big Top
Murder Among The Mateys
Murder At The Deadwood Saloon
Medieval
Top Medieval Mysteries
View All
A Knight of Murder
Murder Among The Mateys
Toga
Top Toga Mysteries
View All
Terror in a Toga
A Knight of Murder
Modern Mysteries
Top Modern Mysteries
View All
Murder in Margaritaland
Trailer Park Tragedy
Murder in Sin City
Summer
Top Summer Mysteries
View All
Cruising For Murder
Murder in Margaritaland
Trailer Park Tragedy
Trailer Park
Top Trailer Park Mysteries
View All
Trailer Park Tragedy
Murder in Margaritaland
Pimp’n HOmicide
Hollywood
Top Hollywood Mysteries
View All
Lights, Camera, MURDER
Y2K Chaos
Pimp’n HOmicide
Vegas
Top Vegas Mysteries
View All
Murder in Sin City
Lights, Camera, MURDER
Killing for the Crown
Wedding/Bachelorette
Top Wedding Mysteries
View All
Till Death Do Us Part
Bachelorettes and Bullets
A Sorority Slaying
School Reunion
Top School Reunion Mysteries
View All
Murder High Reunion
Totally Rad 80s Prom Gone Bad
Horror at Homecoming
Pimpโn Ho
Top Pimpโn Ho Mysteries
View All
Pimp’n HOmicide
Trailer Park Tragedy
Y2K Chaos
Holidays
Top Holidays Mysteries
View All
Terror in Transylvania
Ho Ho Homicide
Murder At Gatsby’s Gala
Halloween
Top Halloween Mysteries
View All
Terror in Transylvania
A Villain’s Vendetta
A Clueless Murder
Christmas
Top Christmas Mysteries
View All
Ho Ho Homicide
Crime at Christmastime
New Years
Top New Years Mysteries
View All
A Killer New Year’s Eve
Murder At Gatsby’s Gala
Murder in Sin City
Cinco De Mayo
Top Cinco de Mayo Mysteries
View All
Murder in Margaritaland
Trailer Park Tragedy
Cruising For Murder
Fantasy
Top Fantasy Mysteries
View All
A Villain’s Vendetta
Once Upon A Murder
Terror in Transylvania
Villains
Top Villains Mysteries
View All
A Villain’s Vendetta
Terror in Transylvania
Once Upon A Murder
Fairy Tale
Top Fairy Tale Mysteries
View All
Once Upon A Murder
Happily Never After
A Villain’s Vendetta
Transylvania
Top Transylvania Mysteries
View All
Terror in Transylvania
A Villain’s Vendetta
Once Upon A Murder
Versions
Most Popular Mysteries
View All
Murder At Gatsby’s Gala
Trailer Park Tragedy
Murder in Sin City
All
Most Popular Mysteries
View All
Murder At Gatsby’s Gala
Trailer Park Tragedy
Murder in Sin City
Adult
Top Adult Mysteries
View All
Y2K Chaos
A Knight of Murder
A Villain’s Vendetta
Clean
Top Clean Mysteries
View All
A Sorority Slaying
Bachelorettes and Bullets
Happily Never After
Teens
Top Teens Mysteries
View All
Y2K Chaos
Trailer Park Tragedy
Happily Never After
Kids
Top Kids Mysteries
View All
Honky-Tonk Takedown
Million Dollar Mystery
The Great Egg Escape
All Female
Top Female Mysteries
View All
Murder At Gatsby’s Gala
Murder At The Juice Joint
A Sorority Slaying
Virtual
Top Virtual Mysteries
View All
Y2K Chaos
Murder in Sin City
Pimp’n HOmicide
LGBT, etc
Top LGBT Mysteries
View All
Murder At Gatsby’s Gala
Totally Rad 80s Prom Gone Bad
Murder At The Juice Joint
Holidays
Top Holidays Mysteries
View All
Cruising For Murder
Honky-Tonk Takedown
Murder in Margaritaland
Escape
Top Escape Mysteries
View All
The Great Egg Escape
Products
Murder Mystery Party Games
Costumes, Decorations, and More!
Gift Cards
Bundle
Subscription
How it Works
How To Play
Step-by-Step Hosting Guide
Party Planning Tools
FAQs
Who We Are
Why Night of Mystery?
Our Story
Meet the Team
Resource Library
Blogs
News
Party Inspiration
Guides
Testimonials
Connect With Us
Customer Support
Share Your Pics with Us
Our Community
Businesses / Partnerships
Sign In
0
No products in the cart.
Search for:
Search
pirate mystery party
Aug 30, 2025 |
2
min read
From Ahoy to Aha! Hilaryโs Hil-AAARGH-ious Murder Among the Mateys | Party of the Month August 2025!
Sep 15, 2021 |
< 1
min read
Murder Among Bethany’s Mateys | Pirate Murder Mystery Party | Party of the Month – September 2021
Aug 21, 2018 |
2
min read
The Perfect Talk Like a Pirate Day P-arrrrrr-ty!!!
Shop
How to Play
Customer Service
