Stock Up on Killer Parties for 2026 – 10% Off Use Code 2026Plan –

Sign In
Search Night of Mystery

Search for:
No products in the cart.

No products in the cart.

Shop Murder Mystery Party Games
- Most Popular
- Themes
  Most Popular Mysteries
  View All
  - All
    Most Popular Mysteries
    View All
  - Top Sellers
    Top Sellers Mysteries
    View All
    - Trending
      Most Popular Mysteries
      View All
      A Villain’s Vendetta Murder Mystery Party Game
      Trailer Park Tragedy Murder Mystery Party Game
      Incredible Candy Caper Mystery Game
    - All Time
      Most Popular Mysteries
      View All
      Trailer Park Tragedy Murder Mystery Party Game
      Totally Rad 80s Prom Gone Bad Murder Mystery Party Game
      Murder At The Juice Joint Murder Mystery Party Game
  - Classic
    Top Classic Mysteries
    View All
    - 1920s
      Top 1920s Mysteries
      View All
      Murder At Gatsby’s Gala Murder Mystery Party Game
      Murder At The Juice Joint Murder Mystery Party Game
      Murder of a Millionaire Murder Mystery Party Game
    - 80s/90s/00s
      Top 80s/90s/00s Mysteries
      View All
      Totally Rad 80s Prom Gone Bad Murder Mystery Party Game
      Murder At The Juice Joint Murder Mystery Party Game
      Happily Never After Murder Mystery Party Game
    - Western
      Top Western Mysteries
      View All
      Murder At The Deadwood Saloon Murder Mystery Party Game
      Happily Never After Murder Mystery Party Game
      Murder Among The Mateys Murder Mystery Party Game
    - Pirates
      Top Pirates Mysteries
      View All
      Murder Among The Mateys Murder Mystery Party Game
      Murder At The Deadwood Saloon Murder Mystery Party Game
      Murder Under The Big Top Murder Mystery Party Game
    - Circus
      Top Circus Mysteries
      View All
      Murder Under The Big Top Murder Mystery Party Game
      Murder Among The Mateys Murder Mystery Party Game
      Murder At The Deadwood Saloon Murder Mystery Party Game
    - Medieval
      Top Medieval Mysteries
      View All
      A Knight of Murder Mystery Party Game
      Murder Among The Mateys Murder Mystery Party Game
    - Toga
      Top Toga Mysteries
      View All
      Terror in a Toga Murder Mystery Party Game
      A Knight of Murder Mystery Party Game
  - Modern Mysteries
    Top Modern Mysteries
    View All
    - Summer
      Top Summer Mysteries
      View All
      Cruising For Murder Mystery Party Game
      Murder in Margaritaland Murder Mystery Party Game
      Trailer Park Tragedy Murder Mystery Party Game
    - Trailer Park
      Top Trailer Park Mysteries
      View All
      Trailer Park Tragedy Murder Mystery Party Game
      Murder in Margaritaland Murder Mystery Party Game
      Pimp’n HOmicide Murder Mystery Party Game
    - Hollywood
      Top Hollywood Mysteries
      View All
      Lights, Camera, MURDER Mystery Party Game
      Y2K Chaos Murder Mystery Party Game
      Pimp’n HOmicide Murder Mystery Party Game
    - Vegas
      Top Vegas Mysteries
      View All
      Murder in Sin City Murder Mystery Party Game
      Lights, Camera, MURDER Mystery Party Game
      Killing for the Crown Murder Mystery Party Game
    - Wedding/Bachelorette
      Top Wedding Mysteries
      View All
      Till Death Do Us Part Murder Mystery Party Game
      Bachelorettes and Bullets Murder Mystery Party Game
      A Sorority Slaying Murder Mystery Party Game
    - School Reunion
      Top School Reunion Mysteries
      View All
      Murder High Reunion Murder Mystery Party Game
      Totally Rad 80s Prom Gone Bad Murder Mystery Party Game
      Horror at Homecoming Murder Mystery Party Game
    - Pimp’n Ho
      Top Pimp’n Ho Mysteries
      View All
      Pimp’n HOmicide Murder Mystery Party Game
      Trailer Park Tragedy Murder Mystery Party Game
      Y2K Chaos Murder Mystery Party Game
  - Holidays
    Top Holidays Mysteries
    View All
    - Halloween
      Top Halloween Mysteries
      View All
      Terror in Transylvania Murder Mystery Party Game
      A Villain’s Vendetta Murder Mystery Party Game
      A Clueless Murder Mystery Party Game
    - Christmas
      Top Christmas Mysteries
      View All
      Ho Ho Homicide Murder Mystery Party Game
      Crime at Christmastime Murder Mystery Party Game
    - New Years
      Top New Years Mysteries
      View All
      A Killer New Year’s Eve Murder Mystery Party Game
      Murder At Gatsby’s Gala Murder Mystery Party Game
      Murder in Sin City Murder Mystery Party Game
    - Cinco De Mayo
      Top Cinco de Mayo Mysteries
      View All
      Murder in Margaritaland Murder Mystery Party Game
      Trailer Park Tragedy Murder Mystery Party Game
      Cruising For Murder Mystery Party Game
  - Fantasy
    Top Fantasy Mysteries
    View All
    - Villains
      Top Villains Mysteries
      View All
      A Villain’s Vendetta Murder Mystery Party Game
      Terror in Transylvania Murder Mystery Party Game
      Once Upon A Murder Mystery Party Game
    - Fairy Tale
      Top Fairy Tale Mysteries
      View All
      Once Upon A Murder Mystery Party Game
      Happily Never After Murder Mystery Party Game
      A Villain’s Vendetta Murder Mystery Party Game
    - Transylvania
      Top Transylvania Mysteries
      View All
      Terror in Transylvania Murder Mystery Party Game
      A Villain’s Vendetta Murder Mystery Party Game
      Once Upon A Murder Mystery Party Game
- Versions
  Most Popular Mysteries
  View All
  - All
    Most Popular Mysteries
    View All
  - Adult
    Top Adult Mysteries
    View All
  - Clean
    Top Clean Mysteries
    View All
  - Teens
    Top Teens Mysteries
    View All
  - Kids
    Top Kids Mysteries
    View All
  - All Female
    Top Female Mysteries
    View All
  - Virtual
    Top Virtual Mysteries
    View All
  - LGBT, etc
    Top LGBT Mysteries
    View All
  - Holidays
    Top Holidays Mysteries
    View All
  - Escape
    Top Escape Mysteries
    View All
    - The Great Egg Escape Mystery Game
Products
How it Works
Who We Are
Resource Library
Connect With Us

Sign In
No products in the cart.

Search for:

pirate character sheets

Murder Among The Mateys Murder Mystery Party Game

Upgrade your game night with a downloadable murder mystery party. With 39+ games, hosting the perfect mystery has never been easier.

Shop Murder Mystery Party Games
- Most Popular
- Summer
- Halloween
- Holiday
- View All
Products
How it Works
Who We Are
Resource Library
- Blogs
- News
- Party Inspiration
- Guides
- Testimonials
Connect With Us

Follow Us

© 2025 Night of Mystery. All rights reserved. Web Design by Lounge Lizard.

Privacy Policy
Terms and Conditions
Game License Agreement
Refund Policy
Scam Alert

DMCA.com Protection Status

Shop
How to Play
Customer Service