Holiday Special! Buy 3 mysteries, get 1 free!

◂ Back to All Mysteries

Murder in Margaritaland

A Night of Crime and Chaos in the Caribbean.

Somewhere in the tropics between the Port of Confusion and Bay of Disarray, you’ll find that murder meets mayhem and the intrigue begins!

While most vacation at Margaritaland, an exclusive tropical resort, to get away from their troubles, for one unfortunate soul, it will mean the end of their travels altogether.

Has the lottery winner’s luck run out? Will it be the bartender who has served his last drink? Is the honeymoon over for two lovebirds before it nearly began? Or will the stars collide for one Hollywood star?

At the resort, the guilty will mingle among the guests and everyone will be left with the task of deciphering between the facts and falsehoods that plague this paradise in order to make a killer pay for their crime.

The night itself will be a clever concoction of chaos, crime, and cocktails in the Caribbean.

We have a virtual version of this Caribbean murder mystery party that can be played in an online platform!

Be sure the “Virtual” button is selected when purchasing.

Download an intro file for the virtual version below in the versions section.

The Cast

*Note that the cast listed below is provided only to give an idea of the types of roles available in this Caribbean murder mystery party, and not presented in any order relevant to the plot. 
Not all cast members are included in every version.

Coconut Joe

Owner of Margaritaland.

The owner of the resort and the man to talk to when anything goes wrong.

Coconut Jane

Wife to Coconut Joe

Jane is in charge of guest relations and will go to any extent to make sure that the guests remain happy and satisfied.

Bindy Barkeep

Bar Manager

With bar profits decreasing lately, Bindy is looking for someone to blame. Will Bindy be able to keep the bar in the black... and their job?

Jack Daniels


Known as the Casanova of the pool bar, it is hard to say whether his philandering ways will get him promoted or in trouble.

Kylie Cocktail

Cocktail Waitress

A gold-digger at heart, her aspirations might be a little ambitious for even her to achieve.

Lifesavin' Sam


Sam is supposed to be the safeguard of the resort, however, after his recent break-up with Kylie Cocktail, his actions have been doing more harm than good.

Cabana Bob

Cabana Boy

Thurston Howard III


Starr Bright

Movie star

Mo Manager

Sandy Beachbum's Manager

Izzie Islander

Island Girl

BJ Baggage


Candy Cotton

Millionaire's girlfriend

Agent Hollywood

Hollywood Agent

Margie Mooner


Sgt. Lord

Police Officer

Tatum Tatt

Tattoo Artist

Lucky Numbers

Lottery Winner

Sandy Beachbum

Professional Surfer

Mike Mooner


Crime Scenes

A picture is worth a thousand words, so take a look at actual Caribbean murder mystery party events hosted by our customers. 


Are You Up for
the Challenge?