Spring Special! Buy 3 mysteries, get 1 free!

◂ Back to All Mysteries

Murder by Midnight

Ring in the new year with a night of murder and merriment at an exclusive Bel Air holiday party!

NOTHING is keeping Regina Baxter from throwing her annual Baxter New Year’s Eve Extravaganza!

And this year the event is guaranteed to be one to remember!

With Bel Air’s elite home for the holidays, a cold case becoming hot again, and the battle for the DA position heating up – the party will be nothing short of show-stopping.

As the clan of fanciful neighbors reunite there is excitement in the air… until one fateful guest falls down DEAD!!!

Leaving the remaining party-goers to solve the murder.

Will it be the power couple exercising one last move before they head to trial?
The budding bourgeoisie on the brink of bankruptcy?
Or possibly the social media socialite with so much to lose?

With scandals swirling, the guests must find the culprit before the clock strikes twelve in this New Year’s Eve murder mystery party!

Join Us to ring in the New Year with a Night of Murder and Merriment!

The Cast

*Note that the cast listed below is provided only to give an idea of the types of roles available in this New Year’s Eve murder mystery party, and not presented in any order relevant to the plot.
Not all cast members are included in every version.

Regina Baxter

Tech Mogul

This powerful, self-built millionaire knows a thing or two about risk assessment… and when to jump ship.

Benjamin Baxter


Male. While investments and have made millions for this mogul, Benjamin’s future may be in jeopardy due to the legitimacy of their practices.

Lucinda Lewis


A leading oncologist, Lucinda’s long hours at the hospital have caused problems for more than her husband.

Gordon Lewis

Retired Golf Pro

Living his best retired life, Gordon isn’t sure if he attracts friends with drama or is the cause of it.

Thomas Brown

District Attorney

Self-righteous and unassuming, this D.A. will not hesitate to prosecute the rich and greedy. Or as some know them, Bel Air’s finest.

Lindsey Brown

Real Estate Guru

A mother of two highly successful children, Lindsey has done more for her children than others give her credit for.

Theo Morgan

Investment Broker

Gorgio Luccini

Fashion Designer

Kris Perez


Charlie Morgan


Billie Luccini


Patricia Morgan


Shayne Williams


Brent Brown


Hayley Brown

Professional Basketball Player

Hunter Luccini

College Hopeful

Kiersten Luccini


Sandy Lloyd

Defense Attorney

Becky Brown


Avery Perez

Reality Star

Crime Scenes

A picture is worth a thousand words, so take a look at actual New Year’s Eve murder mystery party games hosted by our customers. 


Are You Up for
the Challenge?