Totally Gay 80s Prom Gone Bad- LGBT Male

An All-Male Night of Mullets and Mystery!


With their high school career coming to an end, the students of Mayhem High
find themselves battling it out over grades, popularity, affection, class rankings
and what they all have been focused on for years…
who will be awarded the prom king titles?

Will it be the class president who is looking to extend his reign past the
student council? The drill team captain who has used his moves
to land more than a prom court nomination? Or possibly the math
team captain who is desperate to make his name
in something other than academics.

As the night unfolds, the royalty will be rewarded and an innocent life
will be claimed. From the preppie to the punk rocker, the spaz to the stud,
the jock to the jilted—all are suspected although only one is to blame.
Can you find the culprit in this crazy madness that is
filled with neon, naughtiness and narcissistic behavior?

Join These Totally Tubular Teens
and Far Out Faculty For a Night Of
Mullets and Mayhem.



SPECIAL NOTE: Totally Gay 80s Prom Gone Bad is a mystery adapted from another Night of Mystery party -- Horror at Homecoming. If you have played Horror at Homecoming, or want to in the future, we would not suggest this as a party choice for you. All of the elements of the mystery are the same, the theme is the only thing that varies. Any questions or concerns, please email

NOTE: This mystery is an 80s Prom twist on Horror at Homecoming. If you have alread thrown Horror at Homecoming DO NOT purchase this mystery, as it will be the same.

With 20+ guests: at least 14 male characters, at least 6 gender neutral characters.
With 15-20 guests: 12-14 male characters, 3-6 gender neutral characters.
With 10-15 guests: 7-11 male characters, 3-4 gender neutral characters.
With 8-12 guests: 7-9 male characters, 1-3 gender neutral characters.

Peter Prez—Senior Class President. For the past four years, this preppie hasn’t wanted anything more than to rule the school. Peter has lobbied hard for being elected the prom king and won’t let anything stand in the way!

Simon Social—Senior Class Vice-President. A true lover of the 80s, Simon is responsible for, like, planning ALL the details of the prom, and making sure things go exactly according to plan—his plan!

Derek Taunte—Senior Class Treasurer. Spoiled to the bone, this wealthy man has a way with money and a way of using it to get whatever he wants!

Clerical Kyle—Senior Class Secretary. Harboring more than the class records, Kyle’s spaz-tastic personality will stop at nothing to make sure he does not get overlooked...again!

Bobby Backer—Jock. As the leader of the Ravens baseball team, Bobby has made several enemies by using his influence to get what he wants!

Stevie Spirit—Cheerleader. After Stevie’s recent split with Bobby, it is hard to say if Stevie wants Bobby back or wants revenge.

Kevin Catcher—Baseball Player. With his grades falling and chances at college slim, many underestimate Kevin and his abilities.

Seth Sensational—Class Heartthrob. Seth has captured everyone’s heart, including that of his boyfriend, Kevin Catcher. With such a sweet demeanor, are Seth's actions genuine or just an act?

Chet Backer—Gossip. As Bobby’s twin brother, Chet is tired of living in the shadows of his over-achieving brother. For once, Shet is looking to make his own way at the dance!  

Larry Lefty—Outcast. Misunderstood and moody, Larry is one of the overlooked players on the baseball team—but he refuses to be ignored tonight!

J.J. Smart—Valedictorian. A real smarty pants, J.J. has been the head of the class since first grade. With acceptance to Harvard on the line, this individual will make sure it stays that way.

Damian Dancer—Drill Team Captain. As the cheerleader’s arch rival, Damian has danced his way into the heart of Bobby Backer and intends to stay there.

Ryan Rocker—Punk Rocker. As the cheerleader’s date, Ryan is attending for Stevie’s support…but could his hard rocking lifestyle be too much for everyone to handle?

Alan Algebra—Math Team Captain. As the greatest mathlete in Mayhem High history, Alan is upset that the math team is often overlooked. He has vowed to make sure it does not stay that way.

Principal Simpson—Principal of Mayhem High. As newly appointed principal, the principal wants to set and enforce high academic and social standards – but at what cost?

V.P. Patterson—Vice Principal. The second-in-command, V.P. has a lot to prove (and hide) if they plan to continue on in their leadership position.

Dr. Talk—School Counselor. In charge of advising and counseling the students, Dr. Talk may have more knowledge than they let on.

Teach Tanner—Math Teacher. As a popular teacher, Teach Tanner seems to be helping out the students a bit too much. Will their close affiliation with the student body come back to haunt them?

Coach Walters—Baseball Coach. With a chance to win a state baseball championship, Coach Walters is very motivated to make certain they meet all of their goals…at any costs!

Roy Rivers—Alumnus. Back in town for the big dance, Roy may have more planned for the evening than he is letting on.

Find ideas on how to throw an awesome 80s mystery party here!

Find ideas on costumes for your awesome 80s mystery party here!

-- Refresh page if you do not see images.
-- Arrow to the right and left to see all of the options!

80s Outfits

80s Hair

80s Accessories


Find ideas on decorations for your awesome 80s mystery party here!

-- Refresh page if you do not see images.
-- Refresh page if you do not see images.
-- Arrow to the right and left to see all of the options!

80s Decor


Latest Gallery Photos
no gallery photos yet…
Last Player's Exchange Post no posts yet…
Mystery at a glance
Gender RolesMale & Female
Read our FAQ for more on our rating system
Choosing the right Party
Guests Gender Roles Price
8-12 guests 7-9 males, 1-3 neutral $45
10-15 guests 7-11 males, 3-4 neutral $50
15-20 guests 12-14 males, 3-6 neutral $60
20-80 guests Atleast 14 males, 6 neutral $85
Upgrade Add-on for 15-20 guest party $30
Find ideas for decorations, food, costumes, music and more at